| Band | Album | Jahr | Punkte | |
| Izzy Stradlin | River | 2001 | 7.0 | lesen... |
| Izzy Stradlin | 117° | 1998 | 6.0 | lesen... |
| Ivory Tower | Subjective Enemy | 2008 | 6.5 | lesen... |
| Ivory Night | Go Braves | 2008 | Keine Wertung | lesen... |
| Ivanhoe | Lifeline | 2008 | 8.5 | lesen... |
| IronHead | Demo 2004 | 2004 | 8.5 | lesen... |
| IronHead | Livin like we wanna die | 2005 | 9.0 | lesen... |
| Iron Maiden 2 | Fear of the Dark | 1992 | 9.0 | lesen... |
| Iron Maiden 2 | Brave New World | 2000 | 8.0 | lesen... |
| Iron Maiden 2 | The History of Iron Maiden-Part:1 –The early Days | 2004 | 10.0 | lesen... |
| Iron Maiden 2 | Death on the Road | 2006 | 9.0 | lesen... |
| Iron Maiden 2 | with Laura Harris & Trivium | | 7.5 | lesen... |
| Iron Maiden | Powerslave | 1984 | 9.5 | lesen... |
| Iron Maiden | Killers | 1981 | 9.0 | lesen... |
| Iron Maiden | Seventh Son of a Seventh Son | 1988 | 8.5 | lesen... |
| Iron Maiden | Virtual XI | 1998 | 6.5 | lesen... |
| Iron Maiden | Dance of Death | 2003 | 7.5 | lesen... |
| Iron Maiden | Same | 1980 | 9.0 | lesen... |
| Iron Maiden | Somewhere in Time | 1986 | 8.5 | lesen... |
| Iron Maiden | A Matter of Life and Death | 2006 | 8.5 | lesen... |
| Iron Maiden | The Number of the Beast | 1982 | 10.0 | lesen... |
| Iron Maiden | Live after Death | 1985 | 9.5 | lesen... |
| Iron Maiden | Live after Death | 2008 | 10.0 | lesen... |
| Iron Horses | Titan 'n' Bones | 2007 | 6.5 | lesen... |
| Iron Fire | Revenge | 2006 | 5.0 | lesen... |
| Ioannis Anastassakis | Suspension of Disbelief | 2006 | 8.0 | lesen... |
| Intice | Taste The Night | 1989 | 5.5 | lesen... |
| Interstate Blues | El Diablo | 2005 | 6.0 | lesen... |
| Interpol | Our Love to Admire | 2007 | 7.5 | lesen... |
| Internal Disfunction | Nine Feet Under | 2006 | 7.0 | lesen... |
| Innocent Rosie | Demo 2006 | 2006 | 7.5 | lesen... |
| Injustice | Melancholeric | 2008 | 8.0 | lesen... |
| Infinte Horizon | Soul Reducer | 2008 | 6.0 | lesen... |
| Infinite Dreams | Touch my Skin | 2003 | 8.0 | lesen... |
| Infinite Dreams | Big World | 2006 | 7.5 | lesen... |
| Infernäl Mäjesty | None Shall Defy | 1987 | 9.0 | lesen... |
| Infernoise | Chainsaw's Law | 2008 | 8.5 | lesen... |
| Indigo Dying | Same | 2007 | 7.0 | lesen... |
| Incrave | Dead End | 2008 | 8.0 | lesen... |
| Impellitteri | Answer to the Master | 1994 | 8.0 | lesen... |
| Impellitteri | Eye of the Hurricane | 1997 | 9.0 | lesen... |
| Impellitteri | Pedal To The Metal | 2004 | 3.0 | lesen... |
| Impellitteri | Victim of the System | 1993 | 8.0 | lesen... |
| Impellitteri | Stand in Line | 1988 | 6.0 | lesen... |
| Impellitteri | Screaming Symphony | 1996 | 8.5 | lesen... |
| Impellitteri | Pedal to the Metal | 2005 | 7.0 | lesen... |
| Imagika | Feast for the hated | 2008 | 5.0 | lesen... |
| Illuminate | Zeit Der Wölfe | 2008 | 2.0 | lesen... |
| Illdisposed | The Prestige | 2008 | 8.5 | lesen... |
| Ill Nino | One Nation Underground | 2005 | 8.5 | lesen... |
| Ignitor | Take to the sky | 2004 | 7.0 | lesen... |
| Icon | Right between the Eyes | 1989 | 8.0 | lesen... |
| Icon | Night of the Crime | 1985 | 8.0 | lesen... |
| Icon | Same | 1984 | 8.0 | lesen... |
| Icon | An even more perfect Union | 1995 | 7.0 | lesen... |
| Iced Earth | The Dark Saga | 1996 | 9.0 | lesen... |
| Iced Earth | Horror Show | 2001 | 5.0 | lesen... |
| Iced Earth | Framing Armageddon: Something Wicked Part I | 2007 | 7.0 | lesen... |
| Iced Earth | Burnt Offerings | 1995 | 8.5 | lesen... |
| Iced Earth | I walk Among You -EP | 2008 | Keine Wertung | lesen... |
| Iced Earth | Night of the Stormrider | 1991 | 8.0 | lesen... |
| Iced Earth | with Annihilator in Spain | | 8.0 | lesen... |
| Ice Tiger | Love'N'Crime | 1991 | 8.0 | lesen... |
| Icarus Witch | Capture the Magic | 2006 | 5.5 | lesen... |
| Icarus Witch | Songs for the Lost | 2007 | 7.5 | lesen... |
| Ibridoma | Page 26 | 2008 | 5.0 | lesen... |
| Ibridoma | Page 26 | 2008 | 4.5 | lesen... |
| Ian Parry | Visions | 2006 | 8.5 | lesen... |
| Ian Gillan | Live in Anaheim | 2008 | 8.0 | lesen... |
| Ian Gillan | Live in Anaheim-DVD | 2008 | 8.0 | lesen... |
| Iain Ashley Hersey | The Holy Grail | 2005 | 6.5 | lesen... |
